Teaching & Developing Sight-Reading Skills


How to Find the Tempo When Sight-reading:

Rocking, Swinging, and Flowing with the Beat

How do we find an appropriate tempo for a piece of music we’ve never seen or heard before? Sometimes the title can help, particularly in dances (Minuet, Waltz, Gigue, etc.), but only if we have already played quite a number of pieces with those titles. The tempo markings above the first line, usually in Italian, can suggest tempo and character, but cannot be precisely correlated with a metronome (though some metronomes attempt it). The time signature is also important, but cannot by itself tell us what the tempo is, or even necessarily what beat to count. The surest way to find a good tempo is to look at the rhythmic subdivisions found in the score. These, considered in relationship to the time signature and tempo marking, are what help us to set the music in motion in our heads before we start sight-reading.

Our feeling of tempo comes of course from the heartbeat. That is why we also refer to tempo as pulse. In relationship to our pulse, subdivisions have a certain feeling: notes that divide the pulse into 2 have a rocking feeling, notes that divide the beat into 3 have a swinging feeling, and notes that divide the beat into 4 have a flowing feeling. (These are of course purely subjective adjectives; substitute any others you prefer.) In this little piece by Gurlitt, if we imagine the rocking motion of the 8

th notes within the composer’s Andantino marking, we are likely to feel a pulse of about 60 for the quarter note, which as it happens is my heart rate as I write this.

In Türk’s Miniature Rondo (whose opening notes are nearly identical to the Gurlitt), the Poco Presto marking makes us feel the quarter note at 110-120. At this speed, we start to group the beats into 2, feeling the half note as the beat instead of the quarter, and thereby bringing the tempo back in line with our heart rate. With a half note beat, the 8th notes here feel flowing rather than rocking, because they are dividing the beat into 4 rather than 2. In this way, thinking about the feeling of subdivisions, we can not only find a good tempo, but also determine which rhythmic value should receive the beat.

In fact, the 8th notes in Türk’s piece have the same flowing feeling as the 16th notes in this study by Schytte:

The swinging feeling of triple subdivisions is familiar from pieces in 6/8, such as another study by Schytte, which swings well at (again) about 60 to the dotted quarter:

The same swing is felt in quicker waltzes, as in Czerny’s arrangement of a Strauss waltz, where the whole measure becomes the beat. The measures are almost always grouped in pairs, leading to the paradoxical saying that waltzes aren’t in 3, they’re in 2!

Of course, when we are sight-reading we must take our own ability and comfort into consideration when choosing a tempo. But it is wise to choose music that we can read the first time at a tempo near to the ideal one. I always tell my students that the best material for sight-reading is something they can play with at least 80% accuracy and at a tempo at least 80% of the ideal. In this way, we are more likely to come close to Sylvaine Billier’s description of sight-reading as “the art of the first performance,” even if we are only performing for ourselves.

Written by Ken Johansen. This article is from a post published initially on the Read Ahead blog.

Resources & further links

Purchase options

Tags

View next...

Music at Sight

Sight reading is a skill you can develop, but you have to know how. This introductory course teaches the five skills you need to become an excellent sight-reader!... Read >>


Lona Kozik Practising

The Body - Wiser than the Mind?

When we make music we experience fascinating integration of body and mind. As essential as it is to master certain well-defined skills (just as athletes do) there can also be moments when we manage to "get out of our own way" – and everything seems to fall into place beautifully.... Read >>


William Westney Practising

Advanced Sight-Reading Curriculum - Part 3

<h3> <a href="/content/pages/184-advanced-sight-reading-curriculum-part-3?bundle_url=online-academy&amp;last_viewed=true">Playing by Ear</a></h3>

Although playing by ear might seem to be the opposite of sight-reading, we read with our ears as much as with our eyes. The inner ear helps us to navigate a new score, predict what is coming and improvise when the eyes haven’t had enough time to absorb everything. The... Read >>


Ken Johansen Practising

Advanced Sight-Reading Curriculum - Part 1

<h3> <a href="/content/pages/132-advanced-sight-reading-curriculum-part-1?bundle_url=online-academy&amp;last_viewed=true">Eye Training</a></h3>

Sight-reading begins with sight. Before the inner ear can begin to imagine the sound of a score, before the mind can start to decode the patterns it detects, and before the body can translate these sounds and patterns into physical gestures that transform written notes into music, the eyes must... Read >>


Ken Johansen Practising

The Practice Tools Lecture Series

Without an understanding how to approach practising the piano, day-to-day practice can often be unfocussed and unproductive. In this series of video lectures, I identify and explore various practice tools that will help pianists of any level get the most out of their time spent practising.... Read >>


Graham Fitch Practising

Practice Strategies & Approaches

Introductory videos on how to approach and organise your practising for more productive and rewarding sessions.... Read >>


Graham Fitch Practising

The Practice Tools

Graham Fitch's tried and tested practice tools provide highly effective ways to transform your practice sessions into productive and enjoyable experiences.... Read >>


Graham Fitch Practising

Advanced Sight-Reading Curriculum - Part 2

<h3> <a href="/content/pages/144-advanced-sight-reading-curriculum-part-2?bundle_url=online-academy&amp;last_viewed=true">Flexibility</a></h3>

To give an interpretation of a piece we have never seen before requires flexibility and demands a willingness to accept wrong notes, technical stumbles, and botched details, in the greater interest of maintaining rhythmic cohesion, following the broad outlines of the score. The second part of our Advanced Sight-Reading Curriculum... Read >>


Ken Johansen Practising

Mastering Polyrhythms

A polyrhythm (sometimes referred to as a cross rhythm) is the effect produced when two conflicting rhythms are played together and can prove very challenging indeed! This series of articles will help you tackle them in various ratios, starting with the simplest: two-against-three (2:3) or three-against-two (3:2).... Read >>


Graham Fitch Practising

An Overview of the Practice Tools

This series of articles serves as an introduction to Graham Fitch’s practice tools, including how to approach a new piece and the Three Ss.... Read >>


Graham Fitch Practising

Advanced Sight-Reading Curriculum - Part 4

<h3> <a href="/content/pages/174-advanced-sight-reading-curriculum-part-4?bundle_url=online-academy&amp;last_viewed=true">Rhythm</a></h3>

Rhythm is perhaps the most important element in sight-reading and is the subject of the fourth (next) part of our Advanced Sight-Reading Curriculum. Using simple, effective practice methods and carefully-selected pieces with annotations and guidelines, we work on keeping a regular pulse while tackling challenges such as recognising underlying rhythmic... Read >>


Ken Johansen Practising

Advanced Sight-Reading Curriculum

The Advanced Sight-Reading Curriculum is derived from nearly twenty years of experience teaching the freshman sight-reading class for piano majors at the Peabody Conservatory. It consists of an extensive collection of annotated scores dealing with every aspect of sight-reading, together with detailed suggestions on how to practice. It covers everything... Read >>


Ken Johansen Practising

Making Friends With the Notes

<h3> <a href="/content/pages/240-making-friends-with-the-notes?bundle_url=online-academy&amp;last_viewed=true">A Two-Stage Practice Process</a></h3>

William Westney presents a common-sense practising approach for achieving an underlying feeling of physical comfort and security at the piano. This powerful, proven strategy is easy to implement and frees us to play ANY piece of music freely, expressively and spontaneously. It can also lead to technical breakthroughs by thoroughly... Read >>


William Westney Practising

Skeleton Practice

This series of articles will describe how to deconstruct a score and use skeleton practice by way of a number of examples. New articles and examples will be added on an ongoing basis therefore please do watch this space!... Read >>


Graham Fitch Practising

Quarantine-Spots

A chain is only as strong as its weakest link. If you have spots in your pieces that regularly break down you’re going to need to identify them and isolate these sections so you can do some quality, systematic practice on them. This process I call quarantining, and each extract... Read >>


Graham Fitch Practising

Luxuriant Piano Playing

<h3> <a href="/content/pages/178-luxuriant-piano-playing?bundle_url=online-academy&amp;last_viewed=true">A Wellness Philosophy and Practice</a></h3>

In these excerpts from his presentation at NCKP 2021, William Westney shows that whether we are concert performers or beginners, we can all luxuriate in free-flowing, generous, comfortable, unfettered, and unforced movements that “feel great” at the piano.... Read >>


William Westney Practising

Separate Practice

Learning a complex piece each hand alone before putting the hands together is a strategy favoured by the majority of piano teachers. While it is of course possible to practise a fugue hands separately, this misses the point. Rather than working hands separately, I advocate strands separately (playing each line... Read >>


Graham Fitch Practising

Practising for Long-Term Results

In this video, William Westney demonstrates a remarkably easy technique for mind and body to truly “digest” (and remember) what we’ve practised.... Read >>


William Westney Practising

Warm-Ups Revisited

<h3> <a href="/content/pages/164-warm-ups-revisited?bundle_url=online-academy&amp;last_viewed=true">A Body / Mind Approach</a></h3>

In this two-part video lecture, William Westney re-thinks warm-ups and demonstrates an effortless process that takes only a few minutes to ensure successful daily practice.... Read >>


William Westney Practising

Slow Practice

If you’re serious about playing the piano, there’s no getting away from slow practice. It is a cornerstone of our work from the beginner stages right through to the advanced level, and a practice tool also used by professional pianists and seasoned virtuosos all the time. In this section, ... Read >>


Graham Fitch Practising